The winds of change are blowing through the European telecom landscape. After years of blocking cross-border mergers due to competition concerns, the European Commission is now signaling a more open stance. eu telecom mergers

This shift could trigger a wave of consolidation, raising both hopes and anxieties about the future of the industry.

The Driving Force: Funding the Digital Future

The Commission’s change of heart stems from a pressing need: funding for next-generation networks. Upgrading infrastructure to 5G and fiber across the continent is a mammoth task, and many telecom companies are struggling under the financial strain. The hope is that larger, merged entities could unlock economies of scale and attract the necessary investments.

“Creating a true single market for telecommunications services requires a reflection on encouraging cross-border consolidation,” Thierry Breton, the EU’s commissioner responsible for the single market, told the FT. “Scale is key to delivering on the massive investments needed to build the cutting-edge digital infrastructure Europe needs for its competitiveness. Too many regulatory barriers to a true telecom single market still exist.”

Fragmentation: Friend or Foe?

Another argument for consolidation is the current fragmented market. With numerous national players, Europe’s telecom landscape lacks the scale of its global counterparts. This, some argue, hinders competitiveness and innovation. Mergers could create pan-European operators with the clout to compete on a global stage.

In a recent report, ETNO found that European retail markets remain uniquely fragmented and a real European telecom single market remains unaccomplished. The report found that in 2023 Europe counted 45 large mobile operating groups with more than 500.000 customers, as opposed to 8 in the USA, 4 in both China and Japan, and 3 in South Korea.

As a result, in 2022, telecom capex per capita in Europe stood at €109.1, lower than in South Korea (€113.5) and far lower than in the US (€240.3). In absolute terms, however, European telecoms investment reached €59.1bn in 2022, up from €56.3bn the previous year, with 60 to 70 % being dedicated to mobile and fixed network rollouts.

Europe’s ARPU is weakest: mobile ARPU was €15.0 in Europe, as opposed to €42.5 in the USA, €26.5 in South Korea, and €25.9 in Japan. The same is true for fixed broadband ARPU, which was €22.8 in Europe, as opposed to €58.6 in the USA and €24.4 in Japan. Only South Korea was lower (€13.1).

Balancing Act: Competition vs. Efficiency eu telecom mergers

While the potential benefits are alluring, concerns remain. Reduced competition could lead to higher prices and fewer choices for consumers. Additionally, job losses within merged companies and potential dominance by a few big players are worrying prospects. The Commission acknowledges these concerns and emphasizes that any mergers must be conditional, ensuring fair competition and consumer protection.

Spain in the Spotlight: A Bellwether Case

The upcoming decision on the €18.6 billion merger between Orange and MasMovil in Spain will be closely watched. It will serve as a test case for the Commission’s new approach and its ability to balance the need for investment with competition safeguards.

Potential Telecom Mergers in Europe: A Game of Chess with Uncertain Outcomes

With the European Commission opening doors to cross-border mergers, speculation runs wild about potential deals and their implications. Here are a few examples & possibilities, highlighting both potential benefits and concerns:

1. Deutsche Telekom & BT (Germany & UK): eu telecom mergers

• Impact: Creating a European powerhouse with significant 5G rollout muscle and potential cost efficiencies. However, dominance in key markets (Germany, UK) could raise competition concerns.

2. Vodafone & Orange (UK & France):

• Impact: A merger between Orange and Vodafone would have created Europe’s biggest telecom operator with 85 billion euros ($96 billion) in revenues. But, job losses and reduced market options are potential downsides – the merger idea was abandoned.

3. Smaller regional players:

• Impact: Mergers between smaller players could create regional champions, enhancing competitiveness and investment capabilities. However, concerns remain regarding dominance in specific regions and the potential impact on smaller rivals.

As of today, February 15, 2024, the European Commission has not yet approved any major cross-border telecom mergers under their new, more open stance. However, several deals are currently in progress with various stages of completion:

1. Orange-MasMovil (Spain): This €18.6 billion merger between French operator Orange and Spanish operator MasMovil is the most advanced case. The companies filed for regulatory approval in November 2022 and are awaiting the European Commission’s decision, which is expected soon.

2. Vodafone-Three UK (UK): In February 2023, Vodafone announced a £4.3 billion acquisition of Three UK from CK Hutchison. The deal cleared the first phase of the UK Competition and Markets Authority (CMA) investigation but currently faces a more in-depth Phase 2 probe due to potential competition concerns.

3. Iliad-Free Mobile (France): French telecom groups Iliad and Free Mobile announced a merger in April 2023 to create a stronger competitor against Orange and SFR. The French Competition Authority approved the deal with certain conditions in October 2023, and the companies are currently integrating their operations.

4. Deutsche Telekom-Telekom Slovenije (Slovenia): In July 2023, Deutsche Telekom completed the acquisition of Slovenia’s largest telecom operator, Telekom Slovenije, for €340 million. While this is not a cross-border merger, it signifies Deutsche Telekom’s interest in expanding its regional presence.

5. Telecom Italia-Oi (Italy & Brazil): This potential merger involves Italian operator Telecom Italia acquiring Oi, a major Brazilian telecom company. Negotiations are ongoing, but regulatory hurdles and financial complexities remain significant obstacles.

These are just a few examples, and the landscape is constantly evolving. It’s important to stay up-to-date on the latest developments and the European Commission’s final decision on the Orange-MasMovil merger, which will set a precedent for future cases.

Anticipated Impact:

• Investment boost: Mergers could unlock the financial muscle necessary for large-scale network upgrades and 5G rollout, accelerating Europe’s digital transformation.
• Innovation: Increased resources and market reach could spur innovation in areas like cloud computing, edge computing, and IoT (Internet of Things).
• Price impact: The effect on prices is less clear. Mergers could lead to economies of scale and lower operational costs, potentially translating to reduced prices. However, decreased competition in some markets could raise prices for consumers.
• Job losses: Merging companies often result in job cuts due to redundancies and streamlining operations. Mitigating job losses and reskilling initiatives will be crucial.
• Competition: Regulatory bodies will need to tread carefully, balancing the need for consolidation with safeguarding healthy competition and consumer choice.

Uncertain Future: A Crossroads for Europe’s Telecom eu telecom mergers

The changing regulatory landscape presents a crossroads for European telecom. Consolidation could unlock investment and innovation, but it must be managed carefully to avoid harming consumers and competition. As the industry navigates this complex transition, only time will tell whether the new era of mergers delivers on its promises or exacerbates existing challenges.

Like this? "Sharing is caring!"